Ready to take a deep dive and learn how to generate personal tax-free cash flow from your corporation? Enroll in our FREE masterclass here and book a call here
Description:
What if hitting your biggest passive income goal is undoing the tax advantage that made you incorporate in the first place?
Many successful Canadian business owners keep more money in the corporation than they need, invest it, and eventually set a big goal: enough passive income for the business to be “financially free” on its own. It feels like the ultimate safety net. But passive income inside a corporation is taxed at roughly 50% from day one, and once it passes $150,000 it grinds down the small business deduction. At that point you may be paying more tax than if you had earned the money personally.
In this episode, Jon Orr and Kyle Pearce unpack a real client case. The household spends $200,000 to $250,000 a year after tax and now generates about $1 million of passive income a year, much of it from real estate and private lending inside the corporation. They show:
- why a 12% private lending return can shrink to about 6% after corporate tax,
- how integration leaves Ontario owners paying close to 58% instead of the 53.53% top personal rate,
- how shifting toward capital-gains-focused assets, and exploring an IPP or RCA, can keep the reassurance of income while cutting unnecessary tax.
You’ll discover:
- Why a large passive income goal inside your corporation can grind away the small business deduction and leave you worse off than earning the same income as a T4 employee.
- How a capital-gains-focused portfolio compounds faster after tax than high-yield private lending, and why only half of a capital gain is taxable when you eventually sell.
- A staged approach to passive income: use tax-deferred accounts until passive income covers your lifestyle spending, then shift new growth into capital gain assets instead of letting the passive income number balloon.
Press play now to find out whether your passive income goal is building your net worth or quietly handing half of it back in tax.
Next Steps:
Discover which phase of wealth creation you are in. Take our quick assessment and you’ll receive a custom wealth-building pathway that matches your phase and learn our CRA compliant tax optimized strategies. Take that assessment here.
Canadian Wealth Secrets Show Notes Page:
Consider reaching out to Kyle if you’ve been…
- …taking a salary with a goal of stuffing RRSPs;
- …investing inside your corporation without a passive income tax minimization strategy;
- …letting a large sum of liquid assets sit in low interest earning savings accounts;
- …investing corporate dollars into GICs, dividend stocks/funds, or other investments attracting corporate passive income taxes at greater than 50%; or,
- …wondering whether your current corporate wealth management strategy is optimal for your specific situation.
Passive income tax in Canada can quietly reverse the benefits of incorporation. A strong Canadian wealth plan starts by understanding how passive income tax affects your corporation. When retained earnings flow into real estate and private lending, corporate passive income above the $150,000 limit grinds down the small business deduction. Even after RDTOH and integration, it can leave business owners paying more than the top personal rate. A smarter capital gains strategy uses tax-efficient investing and corporation investment strategies so only half of each gain is taxable, while corporate wealth planning and personal vs corporate tax planning keep salary vs dividends in Canada aligned with real lifestyle needs. Tools such as an individual pension plan, a retirement compensation arrangement, RRSP optimization and optimizing RRSP room add tax-sheltered income. A financial buckets and investment bucket strategy separates what must produce cash flow from what should grow. Whether your goal is financial freedom in Canada, financial independence, an early retirement strategy or modest lifestyle wealth, the same financial systems for entrepreneurs apply:
- financial vision setting and passive income planning
- corporate structure optimization and financial diversification in Canada
- real estate investing in Canada and real estate vs renting
- retirement planning tools, estate planning in Canada and legacy planning in Canada
Together, these Canadian tax strategies deliver business owner tax savings, strengthen Canadian entrepreneur finance and support building long-term wealth in Canada.
Transcript:
Jon Orr: This week we spoke with a Canadian successful business owner. Like we do every single week, we spend most of our time on calls like that, talking with successful Canadian business owners and strategizing holistically what their wealth and financial planning systems look like and how we find low-hanging fruit and holes.
This particular case that we want to discuss here today is a person who has hit all of their goals. They’ve hit their business goals, they’ve hit their revenue goals, they’ve hit their personal financial goals. And when you look at the whole picture, there is no doubt that this person will be able to be financially feasible, financial success, financial freedom for the rest of their life if they decided to do that today. There is no issue here.
Their issue was in a way what that goal looks like specifically and where the assets lie because this individual set a goal of saying like I want to make sure that I can sleep better at night. I can make sure that all my fine personal finances are taken care of and I don’t have to worry about that. And it’s all through their business.
And where the issue here is they’re saying hey I generate a good amount of money every year because I set that goal for myself. Passively. I actually created this new problem for myself, which is I have a million dollars of passive income inside my corporation every single year. And that helps me hit all of my financial goals. And actually, it’s better than that.
And now I have to ask myself, because this person came to us with going, like, I pay too much tax. And the issue here is you created this goal for yourself to hit, which is great. But now let’s talk about how you created that goal and really where the mechanics are and how do we fix that because you are paying yourself way too much tax and you don’t have to.
Kyle Pearce: Right, a hundred percent. And this is the part that’s so difficult is like, first of all, who’s gonna say no to that goal? Right, is like a million dollars a year. Just full disclosure, it’s not all in the corporation, but a significant portion of that passive income is in the corporation. There is some personally, but like any successful business owner here in Canada, you know, you’re gonna try to strategize how much you take out at a personal level.
For most people, it’s taking out what you need for lifestyle. Maybe a little extra for that tax-free savings account and for RSPs. So they’re doing a great job there. There’s clearly a lot of retained earnings every year, and there continues to be a lot of retained earnings inside the operating company. And those dollars go up to the holding company and then are sent out into different assets.
Now, like us, a lot of people start this journey along the real estate side of things. I don’t know what it is with entrepreneurs, if it’s just this the tangibleness, being involved, like you know, knowing the asset really well. But you know, we started there with real estate. This individual has a lot of actual real estate, a lot of property, so a lot of equity in there that generates a lot of income as well. But then also started as many real estate investors do going on the other side of the real estate trade, which is like the lending side. So doing some private lending.
And private lending is one of these things where if you know real estate really well, it can be quite lucrative, at least from an ongoing returns basis. So over time, generating enough income inside the corporation every year to not only pay themselves at a personal level for lifestyle. Their lifestyle spend is between 200 and 250 per year as a household of after tax income. They are retaining about one to one and a half million dollars inside of their corporate structure from active income. And over time have managed to grow these investments to a point where they’ve been able to actually achieve this million dollar a year of passive income.
Now, here’s the big problem is a significant portion of it is inside of the corporation. And therefore, there is a significant amount of tax being generated or essentially being paid out every year from this passive income. And we’ve sort of got like, again, a massively awesome problem that’s worth solving here, okay? Which is too much tax, right?
If we’re ever in a too much tax issue, that is a good problem to have for most Canadians. It means that we are doing something really well. Now, from an efficiency standpoint, as you’ve articulated, it’s definitely worth digging in here and trying to unpack this goal.
And I think, you know, if we kind of zoom out and we go all the way back to some of the financial goals we set for ourselves. Those financial goals oftentimes are just like a bean counter, right? So, like this million dollars of passive income per year, here’s the interesting part. If they’re only spending 250 in after tax income per year, like that is a significantly higher goal than is necessary in order to sustain their current lifestyle. So obviously, this goal has likely evolved over time. And we’ll talk a little bit about that a little later in the episode.
But as we get to beyond what you are currently spending or needing, we really do want to pay more attention to what it is that we’re doing, what kind of income are we generating, and where is that income being generated so that we can at least optimize in a way so that we are paying as little in tax. Remember, we never want to pay no tax. That’s really not a good thing. We need to pay some tax. We just want to pay the lowest amounts in each of the different buckets and various buckets that we have. And it really turns out here that this goal that we’ve achieved has actually caused a number of issues on the taxation side. And it’s actually hindering the overall growth of the net worth of the household.
Jon Orr: Right, right. So I think what generally what you and business owners are achieving is that when they open their corporation because they’re saying, Look, I don’t need I make too much money to pay myself like that I need to live on, and therefore I want to leave it inside the corporation to compound.
And when I’m compounding it inside the corporation, I know that when I pay myself, tax will come out at some point. But while I’m in that corporation, I need to be very conscious about what types of investments that I’m investing in because of the different taxes on the different types of investment income that you’re going to receive from these investments.
So talk to us specifically about this because this person’s like, I’m gonna leave it in there. I don’t need to pay myself everything that I earn. I’m doing everything that I’m supposed to be doing. They set themselves a goal likely to say, look, it would be amazing to generate a million dollars inside the business that really allows the business to keep operating the way it’s operating. Cause you can imagine that, right? It’s like I could set a goal of going like I want a million dollars to show up every year without actually manually creating that.
So therefore it’s like almost like I don’t have to worry about active income anymore if because that’s like imagine that like now I’m actually financially free inside the business itself is financially free because it’s saying like I’ve built enough assets inside the business which I was supposed to be doing to allow it to like give the business another million dollars of income that if the business like all my accounts went away or if all my active income went away I still make a million dollars inside the business every year.
Like that’s is a great goal. And I think what you’re saying is like the passive income side is taxed punitively. And there’s a better choices than putting that there. But you’re also helping yourself sleep better at night because I think the goal of like having the business continually compound is really the real goal. And he was setting himself this arbitrary a million dollars because they don’t want the billion dollars. I want my business’s line to grow by a million dollars every year. Great. Okay.
But let’s restructure some of this. So Kyle, what did you help like, cause this this person we talked with, you know, this week, what do we what do we look at? How do we help him specifically think about this? And what do we recommend as the move to make, knowing that all this million dollars of is actually generating passive income and he’s losing fifty percent of it to the tax immediately?
Kyle Pearce: Right, a hundred percent. And here’s like the interesting part is like obviously every business starts somewhere. So every business is kind of like working within that, you know, first five hundred thousand dollars of net operating income every year, right? And we’re paying this low tax rate. And the reason why most people are motivated to start a corporation in the first place is based on the tax deferral, right?
Like so we do this. A lawyer’s gonna say, Whoa, whoa, whoa, what about liability? Like it’s really good for liability as well. But let’s be honest, most people aren’t like as worried about liability as maybe they should be, right? We usually don’t really pay attention there. We think about how do I keep more of this money?
So we started this operating business initially, grew that operating business over time, was able to pay somewhere like from nine to 12%, depending on the territory or the province that they were in. And they were able to reinvest any of that extra money at a corporate level at that lower rate. So, like they kept more of it and they were able to grow and compound it over time. Amazing.
Initially, for this individual, it went into a lot of real estate, right? As it did for me and many of the other people out there that we work with. Doesn’t matter what it was, but over time they took this, you know, we’ll call it 90 cent dollars and they were able to reinvest it instead of maybe taking that 500 out and only really having 50 cent dollars left to kind of work with on, you know, to invest at a personal level. So there’s a massive, massive benefit here in order for people to do this.
Now, as the corporation grows, and this individual also experienced this, they start paying the higher general tax rate on active income. So let’s assume it’s around 25-ish percent. It varies, it’s in the 20s for most provinces and territories. Let’s just assume 25 for easy math. Now it’s like they’ve got 75 cent dollars, still better than 50 cent dollars, and we’re able to reinvest that as well.
What’s eventually happened here by creating this arbitrary $1 million of passive income without considering the tax consequences is we’ve actually gone backwards in our tax planning. So we opened up this corporation because of this like extremely low tax rate that we’re gonna pay on net operating income on the first 500,000. It’s gone up to 25-ish percent, which people are like, ugh, they usually complain about when it first happens, but then they get used to it as well.
And they go, you know what? That’s still better than only getting 50 cents on every dollar. And then now we’ve taken all of this money over time and we’ve created passive income, a million dollars of passive income, which is taxed punitively from day one, and not only takes away and grinds away that small business deduction number.
Right. So that first tax rate is completely gone once we’ve gone over $150,000 in some provinces. Here in Ontario, you know, you only lose the federal, you don’t lose the provincial. But without getting into nuances, you’re paying more tax on your operating income because of this passive income we’re generating.
And then when we hit a million, essentially, like the best way that I can describe what’s happening here is we’ve actually signed up. We’ve agreed to sign up for our corporation to become a T4 individual to these assets. And what I mean by that, to like unpack that a little bit, is why we opened a corporation was because I didn’t want to earn $500,000 a year personally or a million dollars personally. My spend was less than what I was earning. So I protected that income in the corporation so I could pay less tax and then grow it into other things like we’ve done here.
But then at the end of the day, what we signed up for was to pay at least 50% in tax on this passive income, which unpacks and rewinds everything back to where we started, which is getting all this income at a personal level at 50-ish percent tax and the highest tax rates.
Jon Orr: I see. So what you’re saying is like that because this is now inside the business and it’s in its tax punitively at the 50% ish number, it’s the same, it’s the same taxable amount if I in a way I’m getting taxes the same amount if I had no corporation. So imagine I made a million dollars personally every single year, and then I didn’t have to have a corporation to do that, and I just paid myself that million dollars. I’d be in the highest tax bracket and therefore I’m pushing that million, you know, out to me and therefore I’m losing fifty percent ish anyway. And the corporation’s doing nothing for me at that point.
Kyle Pearce: Right. And here’s the other part is like is that this particular individual at this time anyway, and has no real major plans to change this, but the spend of the household is only about a quarter of that million dollars. So like right now, there’s still active income happening in the business. So like they’re it’s not like they want to pull the plug on the active business that they’re running anyway, anytime soon. They’ve gotten to this other goal, which is great, feather in my cap, you know, obviously. You know, fantastic to be able to say you’ve hit and achieved it.
But then from a tax perspective, we’ve actually gone backwards and went, holy smokes, I’m actually producing a million dollars. And here’s the crazy part it actually works out to more. We have an episode, I don’t know the number, but we kind of run the math on it. And in order for us to get that money out to us personally, that million dollars inside the corporation, I’m gonna pick on BC as an example because BC has the full grind down as well.
So we’ll use BC as an example for today. That million dollars is going to initially trigger $506,000 of tax. Now we will get a refundable dividend tax on hand. This is RDTOH. We will get a credit of $306,000, which is essentially the money that the corporation will get back if you choose to take out the dividend at a personal level. And essentially, this is like integration. Our tax system is very complex and unnecessarily complicated.
Jon Orr: Right. Right. You’re not gonna get taxed twice. And I’m using our quotes here, you know. It’s like I’m not getting fifty and not losing fifty percent. And then when I send that out to myself as a dividend, I’m not losing another forty ish or whatever the dividend rate is.
Kyle Pearce: Exactly. But here’s the issue is integration doesn’t work perfectly. And this is a perfect example of where you actually get penalized a little bit harder. Now he’ll have to take out eight hundred thousand dollars in non eligible, assuming it’s non eligible dividends. Let’s say it’s non eligible dividends that he’s gonna take out at a personal level. So 200,000 gets paid by the corporation, the rest of the tax he’s gonna pay at a personal level.
And you’re actually going to typically most provinces, you’re gonna actually net out slightly higher more overall tax than if you earned that million dollars as a T4 employee. So it here in Ontario, it works out to about five percent extra in taxes. So instead of 53.53%, we end up paying closer to 58%.
When all is said and done, like if we actually like do all the bean counting and you can run the math on this, anyone listening, and even some accountants out there may have not done this, you know, this work because it just, you know, wasn’t something you’ve thought about before. But when you do, you’re actually further behind. You’re actually better off to earn the million dollars of passive income we’re generating. You’re better off to earn it as a T4 employee somewhere at a million bucks than it is to do it this way that we’ve got it designed with the corporation. And that is massively, massively problematic.
Now, here’s the other nuance that’s really important to note. We haven’t even factored in this million dollars, a lot of the million dollars coming from rental income. Okay, and that’s one thing we can deal with. That we can take out more mortgages, write off interest, like we can do some things there to try to help us manage that passive income. But on the private lending side, the part that’s really interesting is that the average rate of return for private lending tends to be somewhere in the like eight, nine to maybe 12%, 13, 14%.
When we look at that, but the actual risk associated, especially if it’s an individual deal. So like where we’re actually writing a check for one specific investor, that is a massive amount of concentration risk. And therefore, your overall rate of return, your risk-adjusted rate of return is likely significantly higher than it would be if you were just in, let’s say, a equity-based portfolio or maybe even a balanced portfolio.
And if we run the math and say, let’s say it was a balanced portfolio, which again, a lot of people that you know are in these situations, I wouldn’t recommend balanced portfolios because you have a lot more opportunity to have more equities and you know, we don’t need bonds and we can use insurance and all kinds of things for these other pieces. But if we just use like a 6.6% average rate of return, but keep it mostly capital gains assets that aren’t going to produce passive income or as much passive income each and every year, you’ll actually be net ahead of where you are in this particular scenario, where let’s say I’m earning 12% with private lending, higher risk, that 12% gets chopped in half into six percent. You’re actually at a lower average rate of return because of that tax.
Jon Orr: Because of the tax. Like that’s just you just imagining you’re imagining like forget about the actual dollar amount. I have to pay fifty percent tax. And therefore I’m gonna make sure that I just chop my percent in half instead. Okay, all right.
Kyle Pearce: 100%, 100%. So this is like incredibly difficult. Now here’s the other nuance is that down the road, again, if I’m not selling, you know, right now, they still have active income coming into the business. So we don’t really have a need for this passive income yet at this time. But after like when we do need this income, when we do need, you know, say for retirement or otherwise, we actually have an opportunity to pay significantly less tax based on the capital gains that we might generate on these portfolios.
For example, right? If I’m gonna take a million dollars and turn it into two million dollars, I only have to pay on half of the million dollars as passive income, which means my actual rate of return on the whole capital gain is gonna be around 25% instead of 50%. So there is like a win-win here where year to year the compounding of this income is going to be a much bigger number.
Jon Orr: Right. But does
Kyle Pearce: But then as I sell it, I’m gonna pay about half the actual tax on it as well, which is massively impactful for the net worth of the individual as they are living. But then of course provides all kinds of just added estate benefits just by odd, you know, just by restructuring what we’re doing with these investments.
Jon Orr: Right. Well, help me think about this then, because it’s like if I if I’m equating these two scenarios, like okay, option one is keep doing what you’re doing, and option two is shift into a more balanced portfolio with capital gains type of assets. And therefore you’re saying even at a conservative rate of return on my investment portfolio, it it it I’m gonna I’m gonna be a little bit better off because I’ve lost 50% for my 12 is cut to fift uh six. Over here I’m gonna earn about six. But in in scenario one, I paid the tax to get six. In option two, I haven’t paid the tax yet and I earned six. So is option two still better?
Kyle Pearce: Well, ultimately at the end of the day, if you’re re-compounding, like you’re basically compounding at a six percent instead of a six point six, which is just the number that we pulled out of a hat for a balanced portfolio. Here’s the reality, though, is most of the investors we work with, most of the business owners we work with are actually doing significantly better than six point six percent. So, like we’re being ultra conservative here on six point six.
If you’re earning like so, for example, the managed portfolios of some of our investors that work with our team, you know, did like multiples higher than that over the last 12 months, right? We don’t include that in the actual blueprint because we want to be very ultra conservative. So the reality is, is like it’s going to be nowhere close. But if it was 6.6%, that’s 6.6% with lower risk too. Because remember, if something happens to the private market, like private credit market or whatever. And like some of these loans start going bad and so forth, like that million dollars of passive income could very quickly, you know, turn into a much lower number. And also net worth could be impacted as well.
So just alone, if we’re compounding at 6% a year instead of 6.6% a year, even though we haven’t actually paid the taxes on capital gains yet. The reality is, is we still have to pay the personal taxes to get this money out to a personal level as well with passive income. So the reality is net, net, net, if the return is slightly higher and you’re paying half the amount of tax, you’re going to be massively further ahead.
And as we modeled here for this particular individual, you know, it is a big, huge difference, even when the percentage is a much tighter number. And one of them is being, we’ll say, very conservative, that 6.6% is a very conservative number based on what most portfolios end up looking like and sounding like.
Now, this also, you know, is before we even open the door to the potential of hey, if my personal income needs are a lot higher, let’s say someone’s listening, they go, Listen, I need more than $250,000 of after tax income personally. There are other methods that we could implement or layer in that could also reduce taxes significantly, which may involve leverage strategies. Maybe it’s corporate-owned insurance strategies. Like there’s other strategies that can get layered in here.
But for the low-hanging fruit for this particular individual, is like, all right, let’s address the big, massive, unnecessary tax bill that’s being generated and in doing so over time, it’s like we look at it and say, the small business deduction number, like if we can get that back, because it’s it got grinded away a long time ago, right? you know, eight hundred and fifty thousand dollars per year of passive income, you know, that’s how long ago it was that it was grind away. But is that something that maybe could come back on the table? Well, if we do some restructuring, it is something that could be reintroduced, but even if it doesn’t, maybe we’re so far along here that, you know, the assets and it’s impossible to get us back under 150,000 of passive income.
Keep in mind that lifestyle need that they have would at least allow us to dividend out that passive income. We may not get that $70-ish thousand dollars of tax saving on the first $500,000 of net operating income, but we’re going to be saving about $500,000 per year of unnecessary passive income tax that is actually grinding away at the compounding rate of what we would consider to be like a fairly aggressive investment portfolio that’s very concentrated in real estate and lending.
Jon Orr: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. So so when I’m thinking about this, because you you can you can see that this person, you know, came up with a a a great hypothesis. They said, Look, I I would love to replace the amount of money that my business is generating so that it can it can operate financially free. And they said passive income might be a great place to do that. Let’s set that goal, let’s work, let’s let’s put assets into these types of or let’s put our money into these types of assets to grow to that level to replace that type of income so that if nothing, if if the business went to crap, I’m okay. Because that’s the real goal here. Am I okay? Right? Like, am I okay?
And so, therefore, you know, this move by saying you could you could keep going like that, but you’ve got this tax issue and you want to be okay, and you feel good about seeing consistent income show up in the bank account every year or every month, even. So that’s that’s great, but shifting into a say, even just a balanced portfolio, the way that you described it, there’s enough assets.
If the assets are big enough to generate a million dollars of passive income, the assets also are enough to generate uh enough recurring revenue down the line when I go to start selling some of those assets to in in and take those capital gains so that I could pay myself when I need to. Yes, you’re not, he’s not seeing the money hit the bank account every month. Like he was in the other scenario.
But we have to you have to also understand that if I stopped the business today and then I relied on something like the 4% rule, and I just could pull money from that by selling these types of assets, would I have enough to pay myself? Would I need to pay myself? So again, the business doesn’t need to generate any more money to sustain itself. The answer was yes, because of the number of the amount of assets there was enough to sustain it by just shifting assets into that balanced portfolio. And that can help this person sleep better at night. And again, solve the same goal thereafter. It was like, am I okay? Can the business generate enough if it goes to shit? Yes, it was the answer. And you’re better off. And you’re paying less tax overall, which means you’re compounding your net worth and therefore your legacy and your state at a better rate.
Kyle Pearce: Yeah, I love that. And, you know, for this particular individual, some of the next uh steps and discussions that we’re going to continue, because as we start developing the financial freedom blueprint, which is what we do with anyone who reaches out to us here at Canadian Wealth Secrets and we go down the rabbit hole and we try to find those low-hanging fruit. But then we also want to make sure that, you know, we look at the next ones in line as well.
And, you know, if for example, you know, going from having a passive income goal of like a million dollars a year down to zero is probably not realistic, right? Like we’re gonna have to like ratchet this down slowly over time and you know, see how it feels. Some of the other things that we’re gonna be exploring together are whether maybe the IPP is something that is worth exploring. Because if we do an IPP, maybe there’s an opportunity there where we can still have some passive income.
Jon Orr: What’s an IPP?
Kyle Pearce: So the individual pension plan or a personal pension plan. These are things that can be set up in the corporation with the corporation sponsoring it and essentially creating you a pension. If passive income is what you’re after, then creating a pension might make a lot of sense, right? You’re like, okay, this thing, like the pension is designed such that actuaries are going to, there’s a cost to it, a couple of grand a year, in order to maintain these things. But basically what they’re doing is running the math to ensure that you can get a pension like a check that you get written to yourself once you start taking your IPP pension.
Now, it allows you to put more in there than what you could say with just the RSP alone. So that’s a great benefit. With someone with this level of passive income currently, we might also explore uh RCA, which is a retirement compensation arrangement or uh or agreement. But what this does is it’s usually very uh helpful with high T4 employees, for example. So you might see a lot of pro athletes use RCAs and so forth. So that there’s a way for us to not be fully taxed in the current year.
There are some, we’ll call it downsides to it. It is a little complex to set up, but we’ve got great teams that can assist with it. this is something else that we might explore if, for example, he’s going, you know, like I really want to know that there’s passive income being generated somewhere. Well, if we utilize an RCA structure, there could be the opportunity for us to set it up in such a way so he could still see that passive income being generated if that’s the behavioral piece that he wants, and keeping it tax sheltered.
So an IPP and a RCA are going to still keep everything as a tax shelter. Anything that’s contributed to the structure is going to be a tax deduction. So if it’s coming from the corporate dollars, it’s a tax deduction. If it’s coming from personal dollars, it’s tax deduction, just like it would be for a RRSP. So there are some strategies here.
And this is before we even layer in the opportunity for things like leverage for someone who has so much real estate and for someone who wants a lot of this passive income and is okay with leverage. There are some opportunities that we can consider, especially at a personal level. if they want to use some leverage strategies along the way. And that’s something that we will explore as well. That’ll be a little bit further down the road on that front.
But ultimately at the end of the day, when we look at the goal and then we look at sort of the problem. The problem was tax, but it was like, shoot, I reached this goal, which is fantastic, but it’s now created this massive amount of tax. We’re now in a position where we can go, okay, based on where we are, what are some of the moves that we can make to slowly make this go away little by little and making sure that it still helps the individual and the household feel confident that their strategy is doing what they need it to do over the long term.
Jon Orr: Yeah. Yeah. So we, you know, the those strategies specifically are speaking to this individual. Now, I what I want you to do right now is is roll back like uh years before this happened. So for example, let’s say I’m I’m generating uh retained earnings. I’ve got I got net profit at the end of the year, and I’ve got retained earnings piling up inside my business. You can imagine that you Kyle had you had said, you know, over time the compounding happened to create the million dollars of passive income.
But m if you roll back to say, well, what should we have done 10 years ago? Or what should we have done five years ago? Because if you imagine that if I if I have 350,000 of uh net profit left over in my business and I’m like, well, I should, I could put this here, I could put this here, I could put this here. Four years from now, if I put it all into passive income sources, four years from now is enough to grind down my small business deduction. So it’s gone. Like I’m now all of a sudden paying more tax just because, like, not even putting in passive income. I’ve just lost my small business rate.
So thinking about us, you know, thinking about today, if I’m not there yet and I have money left over in my business, how do I want to think about my passive income stages? Because there’s I think there’s stages here to say, like, what should we be thinking about that to make sure that I’m setting the right goals and choosing the right assets uh to help me with some of these. Some of these goals that I’m setting for myself.
Kyle Pearce: Yeah, well, there’s some people and there’s uh individual we we work with and they have just implemented some of our strategies recently. And uh, you know, I think I had uh made up a name for them on a previous episode. I can’t recall it right now, but this particular individual um is completely fine with generating like no passive income and they’re like all just capital gains assets, you know.
So they’re investing in their their real estate portfolio and they’re limiting the amount of of passive income just through leverage. So trying to keep it like net neutral as best they can. They’ve also got uh investment portfolios as well limiting the amount of passive income being generated through interest or dividends and they’re happy and they know that down the road they’re they’re fine with selling some people aren’t quite there like some people are like this individual we’re talking about today.
Was like, I want to see this money coming in. It’s like just this reassurance that this money keeps coming in. So what I might suggest for those who might be on that path. And I would argue I’m kind of one of these guys. Like I I like, I came out of that pension world and I I like the the knowing that the money is coming type thing. You know, it sort of makes me feel better.
So what I might recommend for some of those individuals is utilize tax deferred accounts for that type of investing. So if that’s you. Maybe consider doing that. And let’s try to get our passive income up to a place where it’s gonna cover what your lifestyle spending is. Okay. And that way, at least you were going to get taxed on that amount anyway. If you’re not using leverage strategies, you could do that as your first goal.
Once you achieve that goal, and where this individual sort of got themselves into a bit of a tax pickle. Is that they then said, well, you know what? It would be great to like replace all of the income from my business, my active income in the business. So they kind of let that number balloon. And now there’s unnecessary tax being paid on that portion.
If we could get that level of passive income happening and continue to grow our capital gain generating assets, if we do that. Then we get the win-win. Because remember, even though you may not want to rely on something like a 4% rule or some people, this particular individual we were talking about today is really has a net worth that puts them at the 1% rule if they wanted to spend as much as they are today for the rest of their lives and pretty much never run out of money. Like they’re at a 1% rule. Like they’re at they’re at a quarter of what the rule of thumb is.
Jon Orr: Right. They could spend four times as much, you is what you’re saying.
Kyle Pearce: Exactly. And be in a similar spot to what other individuals are with that. Again, rule of thumb, not you know, not advice. But with these individuals, if you can at least just if if you need that passive income for your mindset, get them in the right accounts. Try to avoid it in the corporation if possible.
And once you hit the goal of the current spending you have. Start shifting the plan instead of growing the passive income, we now want to start growing the other assets, the other buckets. So we’re talking capital gains assets, we’re talking, you know, maybe it’s ETFs that are going to produce little to no dividends. And then on the other hand, if it’s maybe a managed portfolio, if let’s say you’re like, I don’t want the responsibility of doing this type of thing, making sure that the conversation with the asset managers is very clear that we actually want this to be more capital gain producing instead of income producing.
Usually they’ll work with you on that. I know with our team, we look at every account and we make sure that we’re not only well diversified, but we want to make sure that the buckets that are holding different dollar amounts are doing the right thing for that type of account. And that’s going to be a huge, huge benefit for you over the long run. Now we scratch the itch of the passive income, but we also are generating a solid, strong net worth that if we do choose to dip in at any point, we’re going to be taxed at a much better place than we are currently on, let’s say, the passive income generating assets, especially if they’re generated inside the corporation.
Jon Orr: Right, right. Kyle, any last thoughts for the listener here today to as a a takeaway?
Kyle Pearce: Well, I I think one of the things that you’d probably notice is in the themes of where we’ve gone with our show is that what people want are are simple answers to like a really complex problem. And it’s not just because the tax system’s complex, it’s also because we’re human and we’re complex and everyone has slightly different goals.
And that behavioral side, the emotional side, a lot of times is what is going to steer. you know, steer the ship, right? And we talk a lot about it with, you know, the elephant and the rider, right? When you think about the book switch and so forth. And, you know, the elephant usually wins. And the elephant is the emotional side of our brain.
So the reality is rather than trying to fight the elephant, it’s better understanding how it all works. And then how do we create a system that actually works with us as investors so that we can stick to the plan? It’s not about it being perfect. It’s about it being as perfect for us as possible. And that’s really the type of planning that we try to engage in with all of our incorporated business owners, our high net worth earners, all of these people that have more complex tax uh challenges and need these solutions. We’re here to help you not tell you exactly what you should do. We’re here to help decide what could you do so that you’re going to be in the best position possible over the long term so that you can actually see the plan through.
Jon Orr: Right. So if this is the first time you’ve listened to one of our episodes, then know that we speak with uh individuals like you Kyle just described uh on a daily basis. That’s what we do. And you can reach out to us for us to have a holistic financial review of your situation so that we can help pluck some of that low-hanging fruit or structure a uh a financial plan that gives you this basically the outlook from now until age a hundred. There’s a link in the uh description below. You can click that link, book a call with us.
Uh we don’t meet with every single person that clicks that link. and that’s mostly because we’re uh our time is limited and also we’re specifically looking to support those complex cases, those complex situations. So click that link below and if uh you you can sit meet some of the conditions, we’ll be talking with you very, very soon.